6,613 yards, 133 slope from the Black tees

Years ago I would get in my car each morning for work and within fifteen minutes, would drive by Llanerch, Merion, Aronimink, Waynesborough and yes, Overbrook. The Philadelphia golf scene can be categorized by those on the east or west side of the Schuylkill River and the collection of courses on the west side are primarily within the hills of Main Line Philadelphia arranged mere miles from each other. It was a great drive but one filled with envy as I watched the groups enjoy their rounds in the great outdoors while I was on my way to do less interesting things. Time went by and I was able to be one of those golfers on the courses for the passersby to watch. Overbrook remained the holdout. Very much in the “I’ll get there some day” as I would visit for swim meets and lunches, I saw the course so much I started figuring out the routing. Enough was finally enough and at last, I found myself on the opening tee to explore this Main Line stronghold.

Overbrook’s golf originated at a different site near Lankenau Hospital that started as nine holes but extended to eighteen in 1920, designed by Donald Ross. Flynn then came in for re-design work in 1927. The club remained for over twenty years after Flynn’s work at that location. I live walking distance from it and there are trails behind the hospital. Some of the fairways are still noticeable from how the trees are spaced apart. In 1950, the club moved to its current location at the former Van Horn Ely Estate. Prior to the move, Donald Ross was contacted and advised a bit on the design but in deteriorating health and ultimately passing in 1948, recommended his protege J.B. McGovern to preside over design and construction. McGovern was indeed retained and designed the course, yet passed away the same year the club opened, in 1952. The course experienced the inevitable tides of change over the decades since its opening yet most recently in 2017, Andrew Green performed renostative work here, which included bunker work, expanding and articulating the green surrounds with an emphasis on a transition to short grass, instilling width to the playing corridors lost over time from tree encroachment and an emphasis on the ground game by engaging the lively hills upon which the course is set upon.

I found the course with Green’s work settled in and indeed, the ball ran and bounced about the hills and around the greens. The tee game is contemplative and occasionally placement oriented yet the terrain movement inevitably inserts itself shortly thereafter. The hills and turns with the running of the ball conspire well to render length largely irrelevant, instead the golfer would do well to arrive in a clever, inventive mood, ready to adjust to an array of lies and peculiar shots that will likely arise. Recovery situations range wildly and learning the areas of possible redemption and those of certain purgatory is part of the charming challenge here. In all, the spectrum of golf here on a hilly, some what compact site is impressive.

The First is a 382 yard par 4 (from the Black tees). A gentle ascent from the tee at this dog leg right, bunkers at each side of the turn. The more one flirts with the trees on the right, the shorter the approach and allows for the left to right cant of the fairway. The green is above the fairway, bunkers on both sides and a run off into the next tee area at the rear. The modest size of the greens here places a premium on accuracy yet the surrounds provide enough chance of recovering from missed approaches.

The First
Reaching the turn
Short approach
Looking back

The Second is a 364 yard par 4. A more substantial hill with Godfrey Road to our immediate left, the gateway bunkers ahead are blind from the tee and left center is a favorable line from tee to green. That squares up with the narrow entry point to the green, most of its sides are surrounded with bunkers. The green is well contoured and wide while the rear is free of bunkers, yet I might almost take a bunker shot than putting from the back of the green to the front.

The Second
Short approach
The green

The Third is a 195 yard par 3. A longer par 3 that looks more uphill than it really is and the entry point moves nicely towards the interior of the green. The bunkers are healthy in both width and length, covering a lot of the sides of the green yet just like the hole prior, the rear of the green is spared from the sand. A fine refuge point for those confident with their flat stick.

The Third
The green, from the right

The Fourth is a 431 yard par 4. An uphill dog leg left that leads up to the heights of the clubhouse. The inside of the turn is favorable to allow for the terrain movement towards the outside leading away from the green. That terrain movement is tremendous, which gives these bunkers on the low right a lot more play than may appear at first blush. There is some extra space after the first right bunker that likely collects a lot of the tee shots. The approach is the same configuration as the tee; favor the high left side to account for the cant so that the ball doesn’t move into the right lower bunker.

The Fourth
Moving up the fairway
Bunkering on the right side
Short approach
Looking back

The Fifth is a 535 yard par 5. Precision over length is perhaps on display the most here. Trees on both sides and a fairway that both angles and moves away from the golfer makes for a challenging tee shot. Hugging the tree line on the right or using a ball flight that gets close to them will help with the strong right to left cant. After the turn encountered at the tee shot, the fairway straightens out and begins climbing to the green, bunkers on either side. The green follow suit with its modest size and its sides are guarded by bunkers while the rear has a short grass fall off into rough.

The Fifth
Moving down the fairway
Approach shot territory
Short approach
From the rear, showing the fall off slope

The Sixth is a 466 yard par 4. A much more dramatic dog leg right that moves downhill to the green. The movement to the left at the turn is tremendous, which lessens in intensity the further right one seeks off the tee yet runs the risk of getting blocked out on the approach if the shot is not long enough on that side. The fairway then moves downhill to the green, a right to left cant through the green. The green shows a bit more size and depth here to accommodate the variety of approaches at this longer par 4.

The Sixth
A look at the green from the turn
Approach shot territory

The Seventh is a 205 yard par 3. A longer par 3 where bunkers crowd the throat. The higher right miss is much trickier than the lower left yet there is plenty of room short to work with as well.

The Seventh
The green, from the right

The Eighth is a 422 yard par 4. No fairway bunkers to speak of and straight out, minding the left to right movement of the fairway. The fairway feeds right into the green, which sits diagonally with a bunker on either side. The arrangement leaves the possibility a nice ground approach option and a bit more flexibility.

The Eighth
Moving up the fairway
Approach shot territory
Short approach
Pitching territory

The Ninth is a 474 yard par 4. Back to the clubhouse with this monster par 4. The fairway starts wide but then narrows just about at the tee shot landing distance, which means the golfer needs to decide whether he can hit driver relatively straight to the narrow portion or lay off the tee, which will leave a long approach in. Driver is worth the gamble in my opinion so long as the trees on either side are avoided. One of the larger greens on the front moving back to front and relatively deep with a bunker lining on either side. A leggy finisher that still obligates a measure of precision, especially off the tee.

The Ninth
Long approach
Approach from the left
The green from the right
Looking back

The front nine romps about the south side of the clubhouse and uses the hills effectively for challenging tee shots and approaches that need a good amount of control to avoid the trouble lurking close to the green edges. I would rank them 6, 2, 4, 8, 9, 1, 7, 3, 5.

The back nine starts with the 173 yard par 3 Tenth. Now on the other side of the clubhouse, the green sits downhill from the tee and funnels to the entry point at the front, bunkers creeping in from both sides. Accuracy is still the name of the game with the smaller green size yet there is the option of hedging at the front, then going for the pin from there.

The Tenth
Looking back

The Eleventh is a 437 yard par 4. A slight dog leg left moving to the other side of the property, which means through the valley to the ridge on the other side. The fairway narrows after the bunkers in the distance, once again insisting on focusing at the approach. The green sits on the ridge almost like a saddle and is deeper than it looks, yet also moves from front to back at the rear.

The Eleventh
Moving up the fairway
Short approach

The Twelfth is a 514 yard par 5. A slender crossing back across the valley. There are positional strategic demands with the narrow fairway yet there are no bunkers to worry about until the second shot. The second shot needs to decide how many of the bunkers to try and navigate around. Some may opt to stay short of all of them and come in from a longer distance while those taking on more of them are rewarded with a shorter approach in, which is sorely needed to this smaller green fiercely guarded by bunkers on all sides.

The Twelfth
Moving down the fairway
Approach shot territory
Looking back from the green

The Thirteenth is a 364 yard par 4. Now at the perimeter of the property and moving back across the valley, the tee shot again calls upon precision to get beyond the bunkers on the right, yet come to a rest before the water on the left side of the fairway. Those with 300 yard drives in the bag can consider clearing the water to reach the green complex while everyone else needs to rely upon a much shorter club to pull off coaxing the ball to stay in the fairway. From the fairway, the green is above with a large slope before it moving right to left, towards the water. One really needs to account for the right to left movement, yet a bunker on the high right side tempers just how much of the cant to use. A pretty fun hole.

The Thirteenth
An eagle watching the action
Two eagles, actually
Approach shot territory
At the stream

The Fourteenth is a 321 yard par 4. A blind tee shot that once again takes driver out of hand and the golfer has a downhill fairway towards water to contend with. The closer to the water one gets, the shorter the approach yet those too close with go in. Using the downhill to move the ball and get it to rest within striking distance is key. It’s 300 yards to green from the tee for those wanting a go of it, but the green is shallow and the ball would need to come in very high and stop or at such an angle it would use the width to roll out. The approach is over water and likely a wedge.

The Fourteenth
The green reveals itself over the ridge
Closer
Short approach
Looking back from the green

The Fifteenth is a 174 yard par 3. At the lowest point of the property, the only place to go is up. The green is in the hills. Favor the right side but the thing is, a miss off the green to the right is much more precarious than a miss to the left, but a miss too far left is gone. Hopefully all of that makes sense. Just hit the green and you don’t have to worry about the whole riddle of the miss.

The Fifteenth
The green, from the right
Looking back to the tee

The Sixteenth is a 401 yard par 4. Still along the permitter and now moving handsomely uphill, the fairway moves right to left here. The green is set off to the left with a nice short grass lead up to it. Another chance for the ground game to thrive.

The Sixteenth
Approach shot territory
Short approach
The green, from the right

The Seventeenth is a 357 yard par 4. Two more times across the valley and as we have grown accustomed, the fairway is widest before the bunkers, encouraging a lay up off the tee yet forcing the golfer to gamble with driver and avoid the bunkers scattered before the green. Another go here and I might opt for the lay up on occasion, as one really needs to have his driver on a rope to navigate it to safety. The green is uphill from the fairway sitting on that ridge, the entire left side guarded with a bunker and one at the front right.

The Seventeenth
Approach shot territory

The Eighteenth is a 398 yard par 4. A sinewy finisher where clearing the trees and landing between the group of bunkers off the tee is a success, which then allows some flexibility at the approach. There is a crook just before the green that widens the short grass area that is ideal for those wanting to stay safe, giving the golfer has a good deal of discretion where he would like to come in at the green.

The Eighteenth
Approach shot territory
Short approach
From the right
The green, from the left
Looking back

The back nine uses the valley on the north side of the clubhouse, mostly moving from the ridges on either side but then moving around and past it to the other side before coming back up and finishing atop of it. I would rank them 16, 17, 18, 11, 13, 14, 15, 10, 12.

Generally, Overbrook emphasizes shotmaking, precision and knowledge of terrain movement on its hilly landscape. Length only gets the golfer so far here, delicate placement gets him a lot further. The arrangement can get the golfer defensive and start to miss more than he is used to but that is the point. The variety and how the golfer is called upon to use the hills and contours is an enjoyable challenge yet the bunker placement about the greens is a little rote. With such terrain, there seems to be even more opportunity for runs offs, hollows and short grass around the greens to make those misses more engaging than finding sand most of the time. As it stands, however, the course defends itself well and is a winsome ball striking exam.

Clubhouse/Pro Shop: The extraordinary clubhouse was constructed in 1913 and as the club website explains, “Hardwicke” is recognized as one of the finest examples of French Loire Valley Chateau architecture in the Philadelphia area.

Practice area: The driving range is next to the Eighth tee and a short walk from the clubhouse.

Trending