3,105 yards, slope TBD from the Master tees
Tyler Rae has impressed me for years but the thing that impresses me most about him is the steel shaft in his driver. I first heard about him from the work at Jeffersonville, a course I now look upon as a personal appendage. The course improved, grew in sophistication and became much more popular as his changes came about, all within the thoughtful reign of Rich Shilling, the golf course super. I was then able to get to more and more courses where he had imparted some restorative or renovation work or whatever you want to call it and it all seemed to click with my palate in some wonderful tones. The years unfolded and the projects involving Tyler grew. The brilliance was consistent yet I did have a pressing question for Tyler as I watched him wallop drives with his old school steel shafted driver. You could tell he loved the game as he nonchalantly tapped in his birdies, never even stopping mid- sentence on whatever issue of the game was being discussed at the time. His proficiency in playing is unmatched by that enthusiasm. While he could play well, it was easy to see that was secondary to what came first; just being out there. There seemed to be a lull in the conversation so I brought up what I was wondering.
“Any interest in designing a course of your own?”
A mere few years ago, new golf course construction still paled in comparison to projects that focused on existing courses. Tyler had excelled in restoration projects and was busy as ever but none of that work included course creation. And he wasn’t alone; there are (or were) plenty of designers that find a specialization in working on existing courses, which certainly consists of created components. But no matter. When I posed that question to him, he couldn’t give details but told me to pay attention to the northeast as well as a few other places. And here we are, while Tyler has a few other new courses coming down the pike as well.
Spy Ring is named after the Culper spy ring George Washington formed during the Revolutionary War. His foray into espionage and counter espionage actually predated the war with the first whisps of the Secret Service in place, a circle of soldiers he trusted completely that ended up foiling an attempt to kill him while stationed in New York City. The spy ring was an extension of this and collected critical information on troop movements and battle plans. Washington didn’t even know the identity of the spies and they worked so effectively that none of them were ever revealed. Their efforts led to the British cancelling a planned attack in Rhode Island and the capture of famed British spy Major John Andre. The first new public golf course on Long Island for nearly a quarter century, Spy Ring’s nine holes generally move clockwise around a housing development in, well, a ring. The site was the former venue of Heatherwood Golf Club, which closed in 2020. The name lives on; Heritage by Heatherwood is a new upscale development for the +55 set, which will have the course footsteps away. Opening day is May 6.
Rae has shown restrained sophistication with his restoration and renovation work, all of which demonstrate thoughtful versatility in play. These design concepts are the mainstay here. While nine hole courses often rely on some measure of quirk or outlandish features to instill a sense of strong character in a shorter amount of time, Spy Ring manages a practical gentility as the holes flow from one to the other. The housing is usually off to one side and not really intrusive, although really enormous slices may get a little closer. The fairways take their time transitioning to the greens, feeding right into them for the most part. The topsoil was stripped to expose the sand-based terrain, which was then shaped as Tyler and his team saw fit. This allowed a firm and fast structure, which was accommodated with the use of turf grass up for the occasion. The greens are the epicenter of interest, which reverse engineer every shot all the way back to the tee. Tyler had the most freedom at the greens and they do not disappoint. This is where there is the most to learn, with their various swales and drop offs and undulations. They’re receptive to particular angles and abhor others, which all depends on the type of approach shot decided on and pin position. Indeed, the complexity of the greens will hold up well to repeat play and for many, will be the introduction to studying a course’s features in hopes it continues to reveal itself. There’s a nice variety to the sequencing, which starts off on relatively flat land then ramps up to more undulating as the holes press on. The golfer will delight in the options before him, all of which suggest fun and playfulness over outright challenge. Yet as the golfer gets closer to the hole and realizes all of the shifts in terrain he must navigate to actually get the ball in the hole, the challenge begins to show itself ever so gracefully.
The course is commendable in several respects. The progression of post-Golden Age architecture has been examined on this site the last couple months and we now find ourselves at present day. There was a time not long ago where a nine hole course associated with housing would have been something much different. In the past, such courses were dumbed down, targeting families and non-golfers to maintain a routine customer base, as the more dedicated American golfer would rarely consider nine holes as serious golf. This has all changed, rightly so, and many in fact prefer nine holes, or six, or thirteen. Spy Ring is an example of catering to a much more discerning golfer when it comes to course design. The golfer wants a a much more engaging experience nowadays and expects more out of the design. Rae and the folks at Heritage realized that change in the golfing landscape and provided a course that is every inch as interesting as the pedigreed collection of Long Island courses nearby. Strategy and versatility with a brilliant balance of restraint, Spy Ring provides the golfing public with an endless source of enjoyment that shows just how wonderfully multi-layered the game can be.
Tyler was nice enough to answer a few questions about the course, which provides just about the best perspective possible and instructional on considerations during construction that most of us may not think of at first blush. Here are the highlights.
- In general, he wanted variety and wide plating corridors the most to provide players ample room and to ensure it wouldn’t be a monotonous affair or take 3.5 hours to get around. The client gave them a lot of freedom and trust to build a fun golf course that people wanted to come back to often. That was the goal: make it a popular spot with the locals that isn’t too hard, too tight, or too penal while still being interesting so they feel like it was a legitimate round of golf. The wide corridors and big greens with limited bunkers in an easily walkable routing were all intended as a fun and enjoyable public option in the middle of Long Island.
- With the housing pre-determined, Tyler needed to decide in what direction the holes would run around it, which mainly consisted of deciding whether the hillier land was incorporated in the beginning to start with a bang or build up to a climax at the end. They decided on the latter. This also meant that the out of bounds would be on the left side the majority the round, which is best for right handers and would facilitate pace of play. So the final four holes have the majority of the fun land movement, similar to down the street at, “Devereaux Emmet’s sublime St. Georges G&CC.” (I definitely concur). Yet Tyler points out that the Third has some incredible land movement early in the round with a 50′ drop from tee to fairway and then a 40′ slow rise from fairway to green. And the Fifth also has a nice drop from tee to green and a cliff drop off all sides around the green, which makes it feel hillier than it is. So there is still some undulation even prior to the more dramatic terrain of the closing holes.
- With respect to Golden Age influences on his design, in his own words, “[t]he short Par 3 7th Hole that is surrounded by trouble was inspired by some of the famous, short one-shotters I’ve seen in my life at Kittansett, Sleepy Hollow, Beverly, Fishers Island, NGLA, Chicago, Brookline, etc. Love the sub-150 yard diabolic Par 3’s! As far as styles go, I was thinking a lot about Winged Foot when on the dozer shaping these greens. Many of their greens feature flared up back corners and gentle waves. That was something I thought would help slow down the golf ball so it didn’t run right over the green at Spy Ring. I believe the players traversing the course in the future will have a lower ball flight ball flight due to the wind and other factors present.”
- As I mentioned above, many nine hole courses rely on quirk for memorability and character yet here, that is not the case. In response to a question about the use of quirk, “I feel like the course builds gently from start to finish and it gets hillier and more fun and complex as you work your way through the round. I also didn’t think the public golfer would appreciate a large amonut of quirk so I purposely made it a little more straightforward and “there for the taking”. I don’t mind if someone shoots one of their best nine-hole rounds of their life. That would be exciting and fun. We also purposely designed and built each hole to be layered, where it feels, looks and likely plays more difficult the closer you get to the green; meaning the approach shots and greens defend “par”. I wanted players to tee off with a little less anxiety, which would in turn also help pace of play. Some holes feel wide open, and that’s OK. But those holes might have the wildest greens!“
- With respect to the greens, Tyler and his team know the speeds would be within the range of 8.5 – 11. That freed up their creation process and have some fun, creating large canvases that were nice targets for the public golfer that once on the green, would enjoy the fun, thoughtful internal contours, yet were diligent in not over-doing it.
- A reversible routing was seriously considered and Tyler had a few routings to make that possible but ultimately, the client was so pleased with the single layout that those plans didn’t move forward.
The First is a 340 yard par 4 (from the Masters). Slightly uphill and straight out, a lone fairway bunker on the right imposes across the landscape yet flirting with its left edge or carrying it altogether provides the best look at the green for the approach. The left greenside bunker comes into play for those who steered too far away from the fairway bunker. The fairway runs right into the green, which unintentionally takes on the shape of Maine. A rigid right side while the rear and left sides give a little, the front half moves towards the fairway while the rear half moves towards the rear.






The Second is a 360 yard par 4. The tree line on the looms all the way to the bunker on the outside of the dog leg, which crooks to the right. A tree is on the left, complicating the tee shot by ensuring one can’t simply belt away away from the left side with reckless abandon. After the turn, the wide fairway rolls right into the green with a sole left greenside bunker to consider. The rear drops off rather abruptly as does the right. The green has some broad sweeping rolls that reminded me of Oakland Hills South a little, in how the ball can careen in several different glacial directions, keeping the golfer in suspense the whole time.





The Third is a 520 yard par 5. The tee shot is indeed elevated, the fairway start out below with two staggered bunkers, on the right at first then left. There’s lots of room but the bunkers do their job of making the golfer think twice about placement off the tee. Once past the left bunker, the fairway runs uphill to the green unfettered. The hill makes it tough to see the entirety of the green but it runs back to front and once again, the rear drops off unceremoniously. Simple in presentation yet the shots must be thoughtful in order to score.







The Fourth is a 370 yard par 4. The tee is on the left side with everything in sight almost screaming for a right to left flight, yet I suppose some could fade off of the tree on the left. I also like aiming at the bunker on the right. The fairway has some cant to it as the sides as pulled up. Like the Third, the green is above the fairway yet the fairway feeds right in. The green bends around the front right bunker and ramps down to a separate area, which reminded me a bit of a couple Willie Park greens. The area looks like it is pinnable, which would change the entire dynamic of the hole.







The Fifth is a 185 yard par 3. Even though the playing corridors are straight, the holes play with a variety of angles based on the different tee and green placements. Here, the tee is on the right side playing to the green on the far left. An apron leads to the pushed up green, which falls off precipitously on all sides but the front. A bunker on either side below the green as well, all of it politely suggesting if you’re going to miss, miss short and straight. The green has a terrific left to right tilt with some gentle interior swales that must be accounted for.




The Sixth is a 330 yard par 4. The elevated tee puts the hole on full display and its shorter distance provides strong temptation for many a golfer to put something extra on the swing. Everything moves from right to left and there’s plenty of room before the green and bunker on the left to place a tee shot for a short approach in yet most of us won’t be able to shake off walloping driver for a nice little wedge in if not have it roll on to the green altogether. The green has a Redan and Punchbowl feel to it as moves in the direction of the bunker to the lower left but the bunker is before the green, so only comes into play on the approach or for those who may have mis played their shots off to the right side. The green shows wonderful, strong movement right to left with the rear right corner pulled up, emphasizing the backboard effect and encouraging running approaches into it.






The Seventh is a 145 yard par 3. The course indeed gets a little diabolical with this shorter par 4. The green moves back to front and a bit right to left, towards the quartet of bunkers guarding it from the tee shots. Only an aerial approach will do and some modicum of knowledge on how the green moves will help even more, as the ball will roll from where it lands. Those with longer putts will be challenged, a deft flat stick is in short order and must account for the playful movement.










The Eighth is a 340 yard par 4. The fairway runs along the base of the hillside on the right and all we need to do is get the tee shot straight out to the fairway with a preference towards the right. Length off the tee isn’t necessarily an advantage; like the Sixth, it is up to the golfer’s style and preferences while placement is much more important over sheer brawn. The left side falls off to a barren long grass area and with the green moving to the right, those hitting out of there are left with a tough recovery. If one is proficient enough off the tee and can hit past the ridge on the right, they’ll be rewarded with the ball propelling extra distance towards the green and leaving a short pitch in. So while sheer brawn won’t help, length with accuracy certainly can. The left corner of the green is pulled up and everything moves down from it with a run off area to the right.









The Ninth is a 515 yard par 5. The final hole moves through the hills, turns left and climbs to the green with likely the narrowest fairway on the course. Thera are various lines one can take off the tee and again, the wily among us will consider a shorter club to place among the narrowness while others will be fine with swinging away and using the second shot to get back in position if need be. There’s a lot more room before the bunkers than it appears from the tee so even aiming at them could work for many. Many options come with the second shot yet the overarching mission is to clear the turn and have a direct approach to the green. There are a couple bunkers to contend with sort of the green while there is one greenside at the rear right. It’s fitting that this green takes on the shape of New Hampshire since the First is akin to neighboring Maine, staying true to the New England theme. Wide at the front and narrowing towards the top rear, those going for the pin when it’s in the back will need to be precise. As they say, you go for the king, you best not miss.








The course is an enjoyable mixture of holes that are well varied with strategic versatility. The firm and fast add to the fun yet will sharpen any golfer’s playing acumen with such freedom of the ground game. My ranking of them from my first go around would be 6, 8, 4, 7, 5, 3, 1, 2, 9.
Generally, Spy Ring showcases subtle and sophisticated golf yet has no problems rewarding well played shots. The greens are expansive and well balanced, facilitating study with repeat play and accommodating firm and fast conditions but ensures that all of the contours are meaningful and putting remains a game of skill as opposed to nerves. The options off the tee will begin to reveal themselves over time and many will begin to question whether something other than driver could be advantageous and in several instances, the answer will be in the affirmative. The versatility and variety makes the course a great match play arena, as golfers of wide ranging playing styles will be able to go about the holes in their own way. I found the ground game thrilling and would love to go around with nothing but running punch shots bounding the hills and ridges. In all, Spy Ring is a wonderful addition to the Long Island public golf scene, providing a very thought provoking and inviting venue for golfers of all skill levels to thrive no matter how many times they get around.
Clubhouse/Pro Shop: A simple affair yet well adorned with a nice patio area. The colonial spy logo has potential.






You must be logged in to post a comment.